The 3 Most Unusual Amish Markets in Kentucky
Kentucky’s Amish country isn’t just quaint—it’s bursting with unexpected flavors, rare crafts, and heartwarming stories. For adventurous shoppers and devoted foodies, these three offbeat markets prove Kentucky’s Amish scene rivals anywhere in the states! From incredible sandwiches to legendary pies and bargain bulk buys, here’s where to find the Bluegrass State’s most original Amish markets—and why you’ll want these stops on every road trip.
1. Old Town Amish Food Store – Berea, KY
Address: 1017 Bridge St, Berea, KY 40403
Website: Old Town Amish Food Store
This market is so much more than groceries—it’s a full-blown experience, with a deli counter serving up classic Amish corned beef, Reubens, Cuban sandwiches, and Kentucky-favorite Banana Puddin’. Shoppers delight in the vertical “rainbow” of seasonal produce, homemade jams and jellies, and blocks of butter cheese that locals claim you have to taste to believe. The shop doubles as a restaurant, offering a rich dessert case packed with Amish sweets—think coconut pie, sourdough rolls, and legendary baked goods.
Review Highlights:
- “Willkommen to Old Town Amish Food Store, the most delightful little deli and market in Kentucky.”
- “Drool over the meats and cheeses at the deli counter, then order a sandwich to eat right on the spot. The corned beef, Rueben, and Cuban sandwiches are all fan favorites.”
- “The dessert case here is incredible, with all sorts of Amish-made goodies behind the glass.”
- “The Banana Puddin’ from Old Town Amish Food Store is, pardon the pun, bananas!”onlyinyourstate
Editor’s Excitement: This market stands out for blending Kentucky comfort food with Amish fare—bluegrass meets Old Country in the tastiest way possible!
2. Habegger’s Amish Market – Scottsville, KY
Address: 6013 Scottsville Road, Scottsville, KY 42164
Website: Kentucky Tourism – Habegger’s Amish Market
Habegger’s is a shoppers’ paradise for homemade bread, rolls, baked (not fried!) pies, and country-style jams. The deli makes outstanding sandwiches and stocks a huge variety of bulk foods—beans, flour, spices, and pickles galore. You’ll even find Amish soaps and seasonal produce from local farms. It’s not just a market; it’s a community hub where everyone seems to know everyone, and kindness is standard issue.
Review Highlights:
- “Great place to go, and the best Fried pies I have ever had in my life! They are actually baked so healthy too!!”
- “Amazing fresh sourdough bread & rolls/ buns. Love their coconut pies, fried pies, sandwiches, homemade soaps & so much more. We make at least one- two trips every month just to stock up.”
- “We visited the Amish market and were at ahhhh with all the food selection there was from pies to filling to spices beans pickles I had never seen so many different kinds of everything.”
- “Must stop by! Their sandwiches are fantastic!! Nice selection of spices, soup starters, etc… Super friendly employees! We will be regulars here!”tripadvisor
Editor’s Excitement: Habegger’s is extraordinary for its baked pies, abundant jams, and that neighborly culture that makes shopping feel like a reunion.
3. Sunny Valley Salvage Food Market & South Fork Amish Shops – Liberty, KY (Casey County)
Sunny Valley Salvage Food Market
Address: 2767 S Fork Creek Rd, Liberty, KY 42539
Hours: Monday–Saturday 8am–5pm
Discount groceries, ice cream, meats, and cheeses with unbeatable deals—many items close-dated or recently expired, making it a budget food treasure hunt that’s different every visit.
Lavern’s Country Market
Address: 52 S Fork Creek Rd, Liberty, KY 42539
Fresh, seasonal produce, home-grown bulk groceries, local jams, and beautiful flowers among charming decor—ideal for bargain garden shoppers.
Casey County Produce Auction
Address: 524 S Fork Creek Rd, Liberty, KY 42539
This auction is an event, where Amish and Mennonite growers sell everything from melons to hay by the lot—think old-world meets live theater!explorelibertyky
Review Highlights:
- “Bargain shopping with real friendly Amish staff—every week is a little different, and you never know what incredible deal or goodie you’ll find.”
- “Produce auctions are surprisingly fun—fresh veggies and flowers, competitive but welcoming, and you leave with enough to feed an army.”
- “In Liberty, you’ll find bulk food deals, fresh bread, and country jams—plus, the auctions and greenhouses are worth a full-day adventure!”explorelibertyky
Editor’s Excitement: South Fork’s cluster of shops puts unusual spin on Amish shopping—great for gardeners, canners, and anyone who loves a food adventure.
From savory Cuban sandwiches and Kentucky-style puddin’ to the thrill of a produce auction, Kentucky’s unusual Amish markets offer more than shopping—they’re mini food festivals waiting to surprise and delight! With legendary pies, one-of-a-kind groceries, and bargains you won’t believe, these three stops deliver the state’s most memorable market adventures. Bring a hungry heart and curious spirit—Kentucky’s Amish stores are ready to wow!
- https://www.onlyinyourstate.com/experiences/kentucky/amish-market-ky
- https://www.reddit.com/r/nashville/comments/vu3zw3/anyone_driving_up_to_kentucky_for_the_amish_stores/
- https://www.kentuckytourism.com/explore/habegger’s-amish-market-5009
- https://explorelibertyky.com/amish-mennonite-shops/
- https://www.tripadvisor.com/Attraction_Review-g39838-d8559445-Reviews-Habbeger_s_Amish_Market-Scottsville_Kentucky.html
- https://www.kentuckytourism.com/explore/amish-country-market-10774
- https://www.yelp.com/search?find_desc=Amish+Market&find_loc=Lexington%2C+KY